Showing posts with label LTCG. Show all posts
Showing posts with label LTCG. Show all posts

Saturday, 3 July 2010

Set off of LTCL from Shares against LTCG of Debt Funds

Six Tata Steel preference shares (FV Rs 100 each x 6 = Rs 600) were converted into one equity shares on 01 Sep 2009 by Tata Steel @ Rs. 417.10 (Equity Share closing price on 01 Sep 2009). Earlier the preference shares were alloted on 22 Jan 2008. Thus there is long term capital loss of Rs. Rs 600 - 417.10 = 182.90. Since this was done off market, no STT was paid.

Is it right to consider this loss for offsetting against LT gain from Debt Mutual Funds ( where no STT was paid)?

- Vinayak Bapat

Dear Vinayak, As per the given info, you can set off your LTCL from conversion of Pref. shares against LTCG from Debt fund.

Thanks

Ashal

Saturday, 12 June 2010

Tax liability on the sell of a Gifted property

Sir, At what rate will the sale amount of a freely gifted residential land property by one real brother (who owned it for nearly 20 years ) to another brother (Registry also done in his name last year at the time of gift) suffering from malignant grade 4 brain cancer will be taxed if he has to sell it within 3 years of gift being given? Will the holding period of both the brothers will be clubbed in this case and accordingly will the Capital gains be short term or long term and can purchse of new property/investing in tax free NHAI/PFC bonds after selling it help save Capital gains in this case? Sir, an urgent and precise reply will be of immense help in taking decision to sell or not to sell this property.

Thanks

Atul

 Dear Atul, As the property was hold for 20Y by one brother & then gifted to another brother thru registered transferred deed. For your information, the period of holding `ll be considered from the earlier 20Ys & his own holding period for the 2nd brother as the gift is done between two real brothers & it`s acceptable as per income tax rules.

Now thru an example if i assume that the property was purchased in FY 1988-89 by the first brother, & transferred to 2nd brother in 2008-2009 (20Y holding) & now the sell of the land is executed in current FY 2010-2011, the gains `ll be LTCG & `ll be eligible for indexation.

At the same time, the seller of the plot has the option, to either invest the gain amount to purchase a house or to invest in Cap. Gains Tax saving bonds of RES & NHAI.

Plz. feel free to ask if u need more help.

Thanks

Ashal

Thanks a tonne for your reply as I had to post this message here as I was not getting answers over google to my query or on the tax pages over there. Actually my CA told me that there are conflicting rulings from IT department over such issues and I did`nt want the issue to be messed up or to pay Short term Capital Gains tax.So in this light do you advise me with going ahead sell of the said property as I would be requiring money ?

Thanks 

Atul

Dear Atul, As the gifting was done between 2 real brothers, the gift in question was an immovable property. The property transfer registration was done in the name of recipient of the gift. All the conditions are fulfilled to be eligible for a valid tax free gift.

So the Long Term gains rule `ll apply counting from the original purchase date of the 1st brother (the donor).

As u r in need of money, u may sell ur property. For Cap. Gains part u have the options -

1. Pay LTCG Tax @ 20.6% rate & use remaining amount as per ur requirement
2. Purchase a residential property, priced at least equal to or more than the LTCG amount.
3. Invest the Gain amount in Cap. Gain Saving bonds of NHAI or REC.

Thanks

Ashal

Saturday, 13 March 2010

Tax rate on Long Term Capital Gains

Q. If my only income is property (NormalMale)L.T. Gain-3.5 lac for Ast. Y.09-10,what rate be taxed.Whole @20 or for 3.00-lac@10% & for Bal.50000/-@20%? - Mohit gupta


Ans. Dear Mohit, Here I assume the gain amount of 3.5L Rs. is indexed gain amount. If not calculated already plz. calculate the same. Now comes the question of tax rate on ur indexed LTC gains. Plz. note as ur only source of income is this LTCGain amt. U may set off ur basic exemption limit of 1.6L Rs. so u w'd have to pau Tax on remaining Gain amount = 350000-160000 = 190000 Rs.


As the Indexed LTCGs are taxed @ 20.6%, for ur LTCG the Tax = 190000 * 20.6% = 39140.

Thanks

Ashal

Thursday, 28 January 2010

Availing section 54 benefit on sell of residential house

Question - I made long term captial gains of Rupees 30 Lakhs by selling my mumabi flat on Feb 1, 2008. I did not deposit the money in the Captial Gains Account in the Bank. But I re-invested all the gains in an under-construction residential project on June 1, 2008 (before filing my returns for the year). I claimed the exemption of long term captial gains in my tax returns(AY 2008-2009) by showing this re-investment in under-construction project. However, now after 18 months of booking my flat, I intent to cancel this booking in the under-construction project and re-invest it entirely in a ready to occupy home (before 2 years of selling my mumbai flat). Is my claim of tax exemption(AY 2008-2009) still valid if I do that? If yes, do I need to inform the IT about the change in status of the re-invested home.

Answer - Dear friend, B4 I comment on ur query, here is the Section 54, which u want to use for ur Tax benefit.

Quote -
Section 54

PROFIT ON SALE OF PROPERTY USED FOR RESIDENCE.

(1) Subject to the provisions of sub-section (2), where in the case of an assessee being an individual or a Hindu undivided family, the
capital gain arises from the transfer of a long-term capital asset, being buildings or lands appurtenant thereto, and being a residential house, the income of which is chargeable under the head 'Income from house property' (hereafter in this section referred to as the original asset), and the assessee has within a period of one year before or two years after the date on which the transfer took place purchased, or has within a period of three years after that date constructed, aresidential house, then, instead of the capital gain being charged to income-tax as income of the previous year in which the transfer took place, it shall be dealt with in accordance with the following provisions of this section, that is to say, - (i) If the amount of thecapital gain is greater than the cost of the residential house so purchased or constructed (hereafter in this section referred to as the new asset), the difference between the amount of thecapital gain and the cost of the new asset shall be charged under section 45 as the income of the previous year; and for the purpose of computing in respect of the new asset anycapital gain arising from its transfer within a period of three years of its purchase or construction, as the case may be, the cost shall be nil...........


Unquote -
Now from the facts of ur case, U fulfilled the condition of investing ur money in an under const. house b4 filing of ur return. The same was accepted by the Income Tax department.
Once opted for under construction house, To claim Tax benefit on LTCG, the completion of this house is mandatory within 3Y i.e. on or b4 31st of January 2011.

Here I`m agree with dear subasu that carry over of money from under construction house to ready built house `ll nullify ur earlier claim of Tax benefit on LTCG & u w`d have to pay Tax in this FY (2009-2010).

Thanks

Ashal

Saturday, 19 December 2009

Date of purchase?

Q. - Dear Ashal,

Thanks for the yeoman service you have been doing to help us with our taxes

Now i had one more query on behalf of my neighbor, can the sale of land that was actually paid for say 10 years back but registered only this month attract capital gains tax if sold today? Or its 3 years from the date of registration thats taken into consideration for capital gains tax.. She bought some plantation property 10 years back on instalment scheme and wants to sell it now though it was registered only last month...Thanks in advance. - Radhika Nandlal

Ans. - Dear RN, from the points mentioned by u, the date of allotment (i.e. some 10 years back) 'll be considered as the date of purchase.

The reason is - Installment scheme of pmt. of the price (as agreed upon at the time of allotment) is merely a mechanism to pay the price over a period of time.

The right on the property were created on the date of allotment itself. In between all these years never ever these rights were questioned & both the parties were following the agreement.

Hence for calculation of Capital gains, the date of allotment 'll be considered as the date of purchase.

There r several instances in court cases where the honorable courts have held the views as stated above.

The details of such court cases can be obtained from various sources - Tax advocates, Tax websites, Taxation experts.

Regarding date of registration I'll only say that it's merely a change of names for the property in question in the records of Registrar of Properties.

Thanks

Ashal

Monday, 14 December 2009

UTI Wealth Builder Fund Series II

Q. Dear Ashal,
This fund`s theme seems to be good. Is it worth investing? I am asking, since I have invested in Gold funds (I was going to quit these ones and start investment in Gold ETF). But now i want to know, what will be good.

regards,
MIK


Ans. Dear MIK, this UTI fund is in a class of it`s own. Having at least or more than 65% Eq. exposure (this is to gain from the Taxation window for Eq. MFs) & mandated to not more than 35% in gold ETFs or money market instruments, it`s very hard to compare this fund with any other fund.

The fund is relatively new (just completed it`s 1st year of operation in Nov. 2009). From it`s launch in Nov. 2008, till March 2009 the Eq. as well as Gold market, both were dull. From march 2009 onwards, both these asset class r firing all guns blazing. This may create a misleading picture due to super duper performance.

In future how it`s Eq. component 'll perform is yet to be tested. having only 35% Gold ETF exposure may not give enough diversification for a person who wants to invest a part of his portfolio in gold ETFs. Yes to have a Gold exposure as per ur requirement u w`d have to stop in some of ur other plain Eq. funds to keep the Eq. & Gold ratio in ur portfolio at ur desired level.

Sample this what i mean.

I assume Gold price 17K per 10 gm.

In normal if u want to invest for 1 gm. of gold in ur portfolio ur inv. amount `ll be 1700 Rs.
In case of this UTI Wealth Builder Fund II, to have the same 1 gm. Gold u w`d have to invest around 5K Rs. - 1700 Rs. for 1 gm of Gold & remaining 3300 Rs. for 65% eq. exposure. As u rinvesting additional 3300 Rs. in Eq. thru this fund, u w`d have to stop some of ur other funds. To maintain the over all balance of Eq. & Gold.

In general, people may invest from diversification point of view to have exposure in 2 asset class under a single investment.

Thanks

Ashal...

Friday, 3 July 2009

Benefit of section 54F on LTCG

Dear Mr. Ashal!

Please clarify the following.

Cost of Purchase 2.42 lakhs (1988)
Cost of improvements 1.00 lakh (approx) 1991.

Cost of improvements 0.16 lakhs (1996).

Sold in 2009 2010 for Rs. 82 lakhs.

Invested in REC/NHAI Bonds 50 lakhs.

Bought another residential property Rs. 32 lakhs.

Taxable long term gains is NIL. Am I right?

Thanks - Subasu

Answer - Dear subasu, b4 I comment here I assume the following -

Purchase year is FY 1988-89.
1st improvement year is FY 1991-92.
2nd improvement year is FY 1996-97.
Year of sell is AY 2009-2010 or FY 2008-2009.

Here goes the LTCG calculation.

A. Purchase price = 2.42L Rs.
B. Cost Inflation index (CII) of FY 1988-89 = 161
C. CII for FY 2008-2009 = 582
D. Indexed purchase price = A*C/B = 2.42*582/161 = 8.75L Rs.
E. 1st improvement price = 1.0L Rs.
F. 1st improvement FY CII = 199
G. Indexed 1st improvement price = E*C/F = 2.92L Rs.
H. 2nd improvement price = .16L Rs.
I. 2nd improvement CII = 305
J. Indexed 2nd improvement price = H*C/I = 0.30L Rs.
K. Total Indexed purchase & improvement price = D + G + J = 11.97L Rs.
L. Sell price = 82L Rs.

As more than 3 years r completed for purchase as well as each of improvement also, hence all r eligible for consideration of LTCG.

M. Hence LTCG = L - K = 70.03L Rs.
N. amount invested in LTCG Tax Saving bonds = 50L
O. amount invested in Res. property = 32L Rs.
P. Total invested amount = N + O = 82L Rs.

As the amount in P above is more than M above, so no LTCG Tax liability is there.

Yes u r right.

Thanks

Ashal



Dear Ashal!

Thanks for the prompt response and detailed calculations.

One more modification would be introduced to this calculation because I did not furnish you with that info.

I had financed this purchase in 1988 with the help of Loans from BHEL and Cement Corporation of India. I have not preserved the interest records. The amount was borrowed in 1984, 1985 and 1986 and repaid completely in 1991.

As I do not know the interest quantum, I do not know what to do with that.

Any suggestions would be welcome.
Thanks once again.

Subasu

Dear subasu, as the records of loans are not with u, also the applicable FYs r also date very back.

Hence I'm sorry to say that u can't do anything now.

thanks

Ashal