| Hi, There is a new plan "ICICI Pru Health Saver" in market. This is being called as ULIP and which boast of availing tax benefits u/s 80D for the entire amount invested. Being a ULIP, Because of benefits u/s 80D It looks attractive. Please analyze this plan and give your expert opinion about it. Many Thanks for your time. Regds Vivek Answer - Dear Vivek, earlier the combo of Health Plan & ULIP was available from LIC as well as Reliance but in both these policies, the 80D benefit was not available on investment part. So ICICI Prudential Life Ins. cos. has moved with this cleverly drafted policy. Here the investment part of ur prem. or in other words fund value can only be redeemed against medical treatment/expenses. This policy is a combo of usual mediclaim policy & ULIP. Just dig deep into the skin of this policy & u `l come to know the real truth. First understand what this policy offers? apart from a normal mediclaim benefit, due to investment component from 3rd policy years onwards u can claim more than ur standard Sum assured with a ceiling set by company. Say ur original SA is 3L Rs, after completing 3 policy years u can claim a normal claim of 3L rs. under mediclaim benefit & another 20% of ur accumulated fund value. In other words u can redeem ur fund upto 20% value of fund. This fund value ceiling `ll increase with the years pass & after 10 policy years u can claim 100% of fund value. As per the product brochure of this plan, This policy can be taken as individual plan as well as family floater plan. For individual Plan - Min. entry age is 25 years completed & max. age is 55 years. For family floater Plan - Min. entry age is 90 days & max. age is 55 years. In each of the above policy the maturity age is common i.e. 75 years. Here r the negative aspects of this plan. 1. High Prem. allocation charges - 20% for 1st year, 2 & 3 year 9%, 4-10 years 2% & Nil from 11 year onwards. 2. In case of family floater option, in case of death of primary insured (the eldest member of family), the policy `ll be terminated immediately. 3. Regular prem. pmt. is compulsory for first 5 years for cover continuance option i.e if u don`t want to pay prem. in future to keep policy in force u `ll have to pay prem. for first 5 years. 4. No surrender of policy is allowed except the first 15 day free look period window. 5. Ins. charges for general mediclaim policy as well as policy admin charges `ll be recovered by cancellation of UNITs which `ll impact u severely in prolong bearish phases like the current one. 6. For individual plan option the mly. policy admin charge is 60 Rs. where as for family floater option the same is 90 Rs. 7. A long list of exclusion, which i can`t post here in this limited space of MMB. 8. Actually the health saving option of this policy is similar to our general practice of dipping into our savings to sat off the medical bills. 9. Plz. note the prem. for general mediclaim benefit (known as Hospital insurance benefit in this policy) `ll be charged on ur actual age every month by cancellation of ur UNITs. this is not the case in normal mediclaim policies of Gen. ins. cos. where u pay prem. as per age band of say 31-35, 36-40...... Again this monthly cancellation of UNITs `l impact more in case of bear phases as more UNITs `ll be cancelled to pay insurance prem. per month. In my view - The same effect of mediclaim & saving can be achieved by purchasing a cheaper mediclaim policy as well as investing the surplus amount as per our comfort level in Eq. or Debt funds or anywhere else. So this policy should be avoided. Thanks Ashal |
Friday, 9 January 2009
Health Saver Plan - New Plan from ICICI Prudential Life Insurance Company
Saturday, 3 January 2009
Closure of Insurance Company
If the insurance compnay from which i ahve taken a policy closes down, what will happen to my policy? Is there any policy from the government which will protect my policy?
Answer - Dear Friend, I can't tell u about future as no one knows what lies in future but we can certainly get an indication from history. Some 4 years back there was a Life Ins. co. in India named AMP SANMAR, which was a joint venture between AMP Life insurance Co. of Australia & Sanmar Group from South India. Due to several reasons, both co. decided to part ways & intimated IRDA for their willingness of exiting the business. IRDA intervened & asked Reliance Life Insurance Co. to Take over the business of AMP Sanmar Life Ins. Co. & here comes the most customer friendly act of IRDA in favor of policy holders. Reliance was told to keep older policies run as per the previous Terms & conditions as agreed upon by AMP Sanmar & rel. can't changed these midway.
Another example - Earlier the Gen. ins. business of HDFC was a JV of HDFC & Chubb, later on chubb decided to exit the JV, IRDA allowed HDFC to run the Co. solo till it find another partner & now this co. is known as HDFC ERGO, where ERGO is the new JV partner.
I hope the above examples 'll clear ur doubts. Yes failure of Ins. co. due to extra ordinary high claims or consecutive losses on its investment portfolio (this is not on ULIP but for traditional policies) AIG's case is an example.
Thanks
Ashal
Wednesday, 31 December 2008
How to go for Pension Plans or retirement Planning
How to plan for retirement. I am investing in PPF regularly but very actively looking for retirement from ICICI, HDFC or Metlife. Still not clear on what`s best, looking at following parameters to start with:
a. Minimal Premium Accumulation Charge ( Even if it`s there, then only for regular premium for first few years ).
b. No or very little premium on Top-ups
c. Clear guidelines on Annuity plan ( ICICI explains most clearly but doesn`t give all answers ).
d. Death Benefits ( I don`t want life insurance cover )
e. Any other charges if any should be clearly started in terms on figures on monthly/annual basis, also whether expenses are on NAV or premium paid.
Answer - Dear Friend, Plz. do a simple exercise. Call at least 5-6 Ins. agents from different Ins. cos. & give following details to agents.
1. Age of Person, 60 years (the age u `ll start receiving ur pension)
2. Amount to be invested 1Crore
3. Plan selected - Immediate Annuity Plan.
4. Ask to give benefit Illustration of mly. pension till life of policy holder after that same pension to spouse till life & after that return of purchase price to the legal heirs of policy holder.
Plz. do this exercise with at least 5-6 Ins. cos. inform me for ur findings after completing ur exercise.
Why I`m asking to do so, bcoz when u `ll go thru this exercise, u `ll come to know what the meaning of large corpus creation is? Plz. do note as per my prev. reply of retirement corpus, calculate ur own requirement as per inflation no.
Thanks
Ashal ...
Monday, 29 December 2008
Charges in ULIPs & Mutual Funds
He suggested : In case of ULIP, there are 2 things :
- charges are completely transparent then MFs
- And in long Term (10-15 yrs), ULIPs are cheaper than MFs in terms of charges.
Please suggest and draw some clear picture about charges.
-vivek
In case of MFs there r only 3 types of charges applicable -
1. Entry Load - It can be avoided if u invest directly to ur MF bypassing ur MF agent.
2. Exit Load - It can also be avoided by remaining invested for certain time period in that particular plan.
3. Fund Management Charge - It`s charged as a %age of total assets under the plan. Normally it varies from 0.25% to 2.5% depending upon type of funds (Debt to Eq.) as well as expertise of fund co. for a same set of MF plans, lower FMC Plan is always advisable for investment.
In case of ULIP following 4 types of charges r applicable.
1. Prem. allocation Charge - It may vary from as low as 1% to as high as 65-70% of ur first year prem. & reduced year after year or may remain same at a constant level say 4% or 5%.
2. Mortality Charges = It`s the basic cost of insurance & again it varies among Ins. cos.
3. Policy admin charges - Some ULIPs charge as low as 20 Rs. per month where as some charge as high as 200-300 Rs. per month. Again not constant among Ins. cos.
4. Fund Management charges - From 0.5% to 2.5% depending upon the type of Fund (debt to Equity).
From the above list u can judge urself that in case of MFs there is only 1 charge FMC, which u `ll have to pay but in case of ULIPs there r several charges & no common benchmark is there to see the impact of these charges. I do hope the message is clear to u.
Thanks
Ashal...
Wednesday, 10 December 2008
JEEVAN AASTHA POLICY FROM LIC
Some info for this policy is given below.
Minimum Sum assured = 150000 & can be purchsed in multiples of 30000
Max. Sum assured = No limit
Prem. type = single prem. only
Type of policy = Traditional endowment policy with gtd. return
Minimum entry age = 13 years (nearest birth day)
Max. entry age = 60 years (nearest birth day)
Policy term = 5 years or 10 years
in First policy year the SA = 6 times of Single prem. paid (appx.)
From 2nd year onwards SA = 2 times of single prem. paid (appx.)
Maturity SA = 1/6th of original SA
GTD. addition per year = 100 Rs. for per 000 maturity SA for 10Y plan & 90 Rs. for 5 year plan
Loan & surrender value = after completion of 1st policy year
Sample benefit illustration for a 35year normal healthy male stamdard life.
Age of life assured = 35 years
SA = 300000
Maturity SA = 1/6 of Initial SA = 50000
Single prem. = 48975
Term of policy = 10 years
In case of death during 1st policy year claim amount = Initial SA + GTD addition = 300000 + 5000 (@ 100 Rs. per 000 maturity SA for 50,000 maturity SA)
In case of death during 2nd to 10th year claim amount = 100000 (reduced SA) + GTD. addition of 5000 Rs. per year
Maturity amount after 10 years = 50000 (maturity SA) + 50000 (gtd. addition) + 10000 (lyality addition if any, not gtd.) = 110000 Rs.
From investment point of view (it `ll be the main sales pitch to be adopted by LIC agents al over india), the CAGR for above person = 8.43% with Loyality addition & 7.5% with out Loyality addition of 10000 Rs. which is non gtd.
My Take on jeevan Aastha plan -
It`s a carefully designed Fixed Maturity Plan (FMP). Yes u read it right, it`s indded a FMP as the term as well as returns r known to u before taking the policy & are almost gtd. in nature (just leaving loyality addition as a non gtd. one).
Being an ins. plan offered by the largest Ins. co. of india, it`s also Tax efficient too. In the first year the SA is almost 6 times of single prem. hence 20% prem. to SA rule is taken care off at the time of investment. being investment oriented policy, from 2nd year the SA is reduced immediately to have lesser expenses for mortality charges.
The biggest catch lies in the GTD. bonus calculation.
PLZ. NOTE THE GTD. ADDITION `LL BE CALCULATED ON THE MATURITY SA ONLY WHICH IS 1/6TH OF INITIAL SA.
As the maturity amount is fixed for the policy term, the Net yield (CAGR) `ll be higher for persons in the age bracket of 13-35 years & `ll be very low for the persons in 45-60 age bracket. Anywhere from 6% to 7%. This is due to higher mortality charges for this age bracket.
My Judgement -
- PLZ. DON`T TAKE THIS POLICY. -
Thanks
Ashal