Sunday, 3 May 2009

Tax calculation for STCG on STP from Liquid fund to Equity fund

Q. - Dear Friend,

i have been reading ur post quite long time. please advise on this.

I would like to know the Tax treatment on STP transaction. My transaction are ::

Invested Rs. 49,999 in DSPBR MoneyManager fund on 10th of Dec 2008. Registered STP in DSPBR top 100 equity fund.

started STP from 7th of Jan 2009 for Rs. 4000 every month. so till date total 4 instalments totalin 16000 has been transfered to top 100 equity fund. i understand tax treatment for equity fund. but not for liquid fund. The profit i made each month is

7th jan = Rs. 43
7th Feb = Rs. 57
7th Mar = Rs. 60
7th April = Rs. 65

I would like to know the tax treatment on liquid fund. if there is any tax how it will be taxed(like i need to add in my salary income or some % i have to pay).

If i dont show these incomes to IT Department(i think very few Retail investor use to show these incomes) what will happen.

Waiting for ur reply.

Thanks
Amit

Dear amit, ur STP transactions from Liquid fund to Eq. fund r ok.

The tax treatment is as below.

For Transactions b4 31st of march 2009, the same `ll be treated at STCG & `ll be added to ur income from all other sources & `ll be taxed as per ur tax slab rate in the prev. FU i.e. 2008-2009.

So for total STCG = 43+57+60 = 160 Rs.

As per ur Tax slab the Tax `ll be =

@ 10.3% slab = 17Rs.
@ 20.6% slab = 33 Rs.
@ 30.9% slab = 50 Rs.
@ 33.99% slab = 56 Rs.

Ur April onwards STP `ll be taxable in the same manner for ur income in the current FY i.e 2009-2010.

I hope the message is clear to u now.

thanks

Ashal...

Thursday, 9 April 2009

DEBT funds or DIversified funds for Retirement

Question - 
Hi,
If we see returns of Diversified equity funds for last three years mostly are in red and few are sitting on marginal gains whereas debt funds have given return of 40% over 3 years. Looking at scenario, if i want to invet for my retirement(for 20 Years from now) what is your openinon where should i invest. If you say to invet in Equity MF how should i select for 20 years? If you say Debt funds what are good options available?

Rohit

Answer - Dear rohit, When u r talking for ur retirement, u should n`t compare the past 3 years` returns for ur future 20 years.

Just for ur info, Eq. is the only asset class which `ll provide inflation adjusted best returns over such long 20 years.

Now look at the following No.

On 31st of march 1989 (i.e. 20 years back) the SENSEX level was 713.60 & on 31st March 2009 the sensex level was 9708.50.

The above Nos. tell the CAGR of Sensex for past 20 years = 13.94% or almost 14%. Even if u adjust 7% inflation rate for all these 20 years, still u r getting 7% positive return over the inflation.

In my view u should invest in 3 large cap funds thru SIP. Check the performance of ur funds once in a year. If the performance is in line with over all market performance it`s ok to continue ur SIP, if the performance lags continuously for 3-4 quarters, switch ur SIP to a better performing fund. After 14-15 years, Stop fresh SIP in large cap funds. Divert SIP amount to balanced funds & gradually shift ur money from Eq. funds to Debt funds when ur retirement is closer to u. 

After 20 years, when u r retired, u should n`t have more than 15-20% money in Eq. funds.

Thanks

Ashal ...

Thursday, 19 February 2009

Split Term Cover

Dear Friends, Many a times I & several others had advised to opt split Term Covers. But a common person is not able to understand the logic & benefit offered by split Term Covers. Here I’m discussing the benefit of split Term Cover with the prem. Illustrations of LIC’s Anmol Jeevan Term Plan. 

Let’s assume a normal healthy male aged 30 years wants to take term cover of 60L as per his financial liabilities for next 25 years. The different prem. Quotes (service Tax included in the prem.) are given below. 

 

Table – 1 for LIC Anmol Jeevan Plan

Cover amount

Term

Premium

6000000

25

22928

1500000

25

5732

1500000

20

4841

1500000

15

4217

1500000

10

3846

Split Cover Total Prem.

18636

 

 Now from Table -1,

If the person opts a single cover of 60L Rs. for next 25 years, the prem. Outgo is 22928 Rs. Now imagine the situation after 8-10 years, He thinks there is no need for such high cover & a lower cover of say 40-45L is sufficient. But he can’t do anything bcoz if he opts to stop his current single cover of 60L Rs. the prem. For new cover of 40-45L ‘ll be higher for remaining period as he is taking the cover at later age. If he opts to remain with the single cover, he is paying prem. For the cover he doesn’t require.

Now for split covers of 15L each for 25, 20, 15 & 10 years the total prem. Outgo is18636 Rs. only. On a first hand there is an immediate saving of appx. 4300 Rs. per annum & the best part is after 8-10 years the person in question can simply stop his 10Y 15L policy as per his changed cover requirement. Already he is paying less prem. Every year for split cover than a single cover & after stopping the 10 year policy. There ‘ll be additional saving of 3846 Rs. These saving amounts can be invested for better investment. The same thing can be done to other policies also one by one after passing of some more years. 

 On a concluding note, it’s finally the choice of the person what he wants. The major flip side or should I say negative side of this strategy of split cover is, in case the financial liabilities increase (normally Fin. Liabs. Decreased, but in extra ordinary cases it may increase also), There ‘ll be shortage of cover & the person ‘ll have to take more cover as per his changed liabilities. 

Jeevan Varsha - New Guaranteed Return Money Back Plan from LIC

Dear friends, There is a new money back product on offer from LIC with GTD. Returns. The plan is open for purchase from 16th February, 2009 to 31st March, 2009.  The prem. paid are eligible for Section 80C Tax benefits as well as money back & maturity amounts are also Tax free underSection  10 (10) (D). Here is the plan scan for benefit of all of you.

ELIGIBILITY CONDITIONS

Minimum Entry Age: 15 years (completed)

Maximum Entry Age: 66 years (Nearest Birthday) for 9 years term policy, 63 years (Nearest Birthday) for 12 years term policy

Policy Term : 9 years & 12 years

Premium Paying Term: 9 years

Maximum Maturity Age: 75years (Nearest Birthday)

Minimum Sum Assured: Rs. 75,000/- for monthly ECS mode               : Rs. 50,000/- for other modes

Maximum Sum Assured: No limit 

PREMIUM PAYMENT MODES: Yearly, Half-Yearly, Quarterly, Monthly (by ECS mode only).

Survival Benefits:

For 9 Years Policy Term

15% of the Sum Assured is payable at the end of 3 years.

25% of the Sum Assured is payable at the end of 6 years.

60% of the Sum Assured is payable together with Guaranteed Additions, and Loyalty Addition, if any, at the end of 9 years.

For 12 Years Policy Term

10% of the Sum Assured is payable at the end of 3 years.

20% of the Sum Assured is payable at the end of 6 years.

30% of the Sum Assured is payable at the end of 9 years

40% of the Sum Assured is payable together with Guaranteed Additions, and Loyalty Addition, if any, at the end of 12 years.

Death Benefit:

In case of death of the life assured during the policy term, the full sum assured is payable irrespective of the survival benefits paid earlier.

On death during the policy term excluding last policy year: Sum Assured with accrued Guaranteed Additions

On death during last policy year: Sum Assured with accrued Guaranteed Additions along with Loyalty Addition, if any.

Guaranteed Addition :

The policy provides for Guaranteed Addition at the following rates:

Rs. 65 per thousand Sum Assured per year for a policy of 9 years term.

Rs. 70 per thousand Sum Assured per year for a policy of 12 years term.

I calculated the return generated by this policy for a healthy male aged 30 years & sum assured of 10L Rs. with annual prem. Mode (to get highest rebate on tabular prem. Thru annual prem. Mode & high sum assured) for both term 9 & 12 years. For 9Y policy the prem. is 153909 Rs. per annum & for 12Y policy the prem. is 157094 Rs. per annum. Now plz. Go thru the following calculation. Here I had assumed the money back received from the policy ‘ll be reinvested till maturity of policy to earn post tax return of 8%.

1. 9Y Term

A. Total prem. paid over the policy term = 1385181 Rs.

B. 1st M/B (Money Back) after 3Y = 150000

C. Value of B at policy maturity (after remaining 6Y) = 238031

D.  2nd M/B after 6Y = 250000

E. Value of D at policy maturity = 314928

F. Final M/B at policy maturity = 600000

G. Gtd. Addition @ 65 Rs. per annum per 1000 SA = 585000

H. Loyality addition (not Gtd.) = 50000

I. Total Maturity amount =  C+E+F+G+H = 1788000 Rs. appx.

For an annual prem. of 1.54L Rs. The I above (maturity amount) is @ 5% rate of return only.

2. 12Y Term

A. Total prem. paid over the policy term = 1413846 Rs.

B. 1st M/B after 3Y = 100000

C. Value of B at policy maturity (after remaining 6Y) = 199900

D.  2nd M/B after 6Y = 200000

E. Value of D at policy maturity = 317374

F. 3rd M/B after 9Y = 300000

G. Value of F at policy maturity = 377913

H. Final M/B at policy maturity = 400000

I. Gtd. Addition @ 70 Rs. per annum per 1000 SA = 840000

J. Loyality addition (not Gtd.) = 75000

K. Total Maturity amount =  C+E+G+H+I+J = 2210000 Rs. appx.

For an annual prem. of 1.57L Rs. The K above (maturity amount) is @ 5.62% rate of return only.

 

Conclusion –  From the above calculation, everyone can see itself that the returns generated by this policy r not that much impressive as it looks on first glance. For lower Sum assured say 1L or 2L Rs. & for higher age the returns ‘ll be even lower. Also there is no guarantee of Loyality addition which I had considered in my calculation.

Plz. Don’t fall in the trap of gtd. Returns offered by this policy. It’s making wealth for LIC & it’s agents only, not for U, the Policy Holder. 

Monday, 19 January 2009

14.16% or 33.99%? Which Tax Rate is higher?

Strange isn’t it! With out doubt majority of U ‘ll declare 14.16% as lower Tax than 33.99%. Some of u may be thinking what I’m talking about? My dear friends my question is quite interesting & a valid one. Let me clear u what I’m asking?

All of us already aware that Div. Distribution Tax on Debt based MFs is 14.16% where as STCG Tax on debt funds for a person in the highest Tax slab is 33.99%. Now think again on my question & answer.

Now read below to find the truth –

I assume there r 2 investors Mr. Sharma & Mr. Kapoor. Both r in the highest Tax slab of 33.99%. Now both have a surplus saving of 10L Rs. Which both want to invest in secure debt funds. There is a debt fund available for investment @ NAV of 10 Rs. for both Growth as well as Div. payout option. Mr. Sharma opts to invest in Div. payout option. While Mr. Kapoor has some other plans & invest in Growth option. From 10L Rs. each has been allotted 1L Units. On 364th day, the NAV of the fund for both option is 12 Rs.

Div. pay out option – The fund announces a div. pay out of 10% per Unit i.e. 1 Rs. per unit.
A. Div. Amount = 1*No. of Units = 1*100000 = 100000 Rs.
B. Total amount withdrawn from fund including Div. Distribution Tax = 100000/0.8584 = 116496 Rs.
C. Hence DDT = B-A = 16496
D. Per Unit of fund, the impact of Div. = 116496/100000 = 1.165 Rs.
E. Post Div. NAV of fund = 12-1.165 = 10.835 Rs.
F. Value of investment after Div. distribution = E* 100000 = 1083500


Growth Option – In parallel to Div. amount of 1L Rs., Mr. Kapoor decides to book STCG. Here is his calculation

A. No. of UNITs redeemed for STCG = 8833.8
B. Redeemed amount = Per Unit NAV*A = 12*8833.8 = 106005.6
C. Per UNIT STCG = 12-10 = 2 Rs.
D. Tax on C @ 33.99% = 0.6798 Rs.
E. Total STCG Tax = A*D = 6005.6
F. Redeemed amount net of STCG Tax = B-E = 100000 (Equal to Div. Received under Div. pay out option)
G. Total No. of Units remain = 100000 – A = 91166.2
H. Value of investment post STCG = G*NAV of UNIT = 1093994.4

Now all of us can look, DDT (@ 14.16% ) is higher than STCG Tax (@ 33.99%) due to which the value of investment is higher for Mr. KAPOOR.
So it’s now for all of U guys to decide what to do in case of investment in Debt funds.
The above calculation once again proves that don’t look at the nos. for what they appear at first glance, just dig deep & u ‘ll see another truth.

Thanks

Ashal