My blog is for indian investor. You may get advise/articles/messages here of Income tax for individuals,Mutual Funds,Insurance(Life & General),Estate planning, Loans etc.
The blogger/blog 'll not be held responsible for any financial or monetery loss to the person acting on the INFO provided in this blog as the content of this blog may be changed/updated any time by the blogger.Act on the info of this blog at ur own risk.
We have bought a residential bungalow worth Rs. 41 lacs, and we are three joint holders of the property (Me, my wife and my father). We have taken home loan of Rs.32.8 lacs (80% of actual price) from bank. I and my wife are working as salaried employees of an IT firm and we are repaying the loan, where loan installment per month is Rs.27000 (16000 and 11000 paid by me and my wife respectively).
Now, my queries are as follows:
1. Is it possible that I can take the loan of Rs.6 lac from my mother, to pay rest of the bungalow price? If yes, then what are the tax implications for me & my wife as well as my mother & what are the legal documents required for the same?
2. Can I & my wife both avail the tax exemption on home loan interest (for loan from bank as well as from my mother)? If yes, then what shall be ratio to avail exemption?
Ans. Dear Friend, First let me understand from ur query.
A. Property Cost = 41L B. No. of owners = 3 (U, ur wife & ur father) C. Amount pitch in by U & ur wife thru bank loan = 32.8L D. Additional amount pitch in by both of u = 6L from ur mother as home loan E. Balance amount = 41 - (32.8+6) = 2.2L
Here I assume, that this 2.2L Rs. r coming from ur father only. Even if both of u do have a part in this 2.2L amt. also plz. do inform me for the same.
As per my assumption share of both of u in the house = 38.8L Rs.
Share in Bank loan EMI = 16000 & 11000 & the same ratio both of u may continue for ur mother`s loan.
Now here comes the answer for ur queries.
1. Yes it`s possible for both of u to take home loan of additional 6L Rs. for the same house from ur mother. The interest paid for this loan to ur mother, `ll be available for Tax benefit for both of u in the ratio as stated above. The interest received by ur mother from both of u `ll be her taxable income & if her total income from all other sources is more than the zero tax limit for her (1.9L Rs. or 2.4L Rs, depending upon her age, as the case may be), she w`d have to pay Tax on it. For this loan, u should prepare a loan agreement between ur mother & both of U.
2. Yes both of u can avail tax benefit on the interest & principal repmt. of bank loan & interest only for mother`s loan. But from ur query it seems that the house in Question `ll be self occupied, hence u & ur wife can`t claim more than 1.5L Rs. each, (1.5+1.5 = 3L) interest on combine loan.
For detailed info u may mail me directly to my mail id.
Cost of Purchase 2.42 lakhs (1988) Cost of improvements 1.00 lakh (approx) 1991.
Cost of improvements 0.16 lakhs (1996).
Sold in 2009 2010 for Rs. 82 lakhs.
Invested in REC/NHAI Bonds 50 lakhs.
Bought another residential property Rs. 32 lakhs.
Taxable long term gains is NIL. Am I right?
Thanks - Subasu
Answer - Dear subasu, b4 I comment here I assume the following -
Purchase year is FY 1988-89. 1st improvement year is FY 1991-92. 2nd improvement year is FY 1996-97. Year of sell is AY 2009-2010 or FY 2008-2009.
Here goes the LTCG calculation.
A. Purchase price = 2.42L Rs. B. Cost Inflation index (CII) of FY 1988-89 = 161 C. CII for FY 2008-2009 = 582 D. Indexed purchase price = A*C/B = 2.42*582/161 = 8.75L Rs. E. 1st improvement price = 1.0L Rs. F. 1st improvement FY CII = 199 G. Indexed 1st improvement price = E*C/F = 2.92L Rs. H. 2nd improvement price = .16L Rs. I. 2nd improvement CII = 305 J. Indexed 2nd improvement price = H*C/I = 0.30L Rs. K. Total Indexed purchase & improvement price = D + G + J = 11.97L Rs. L. Sell price = 82L Rs.
As more than 3 years r completed for purchase as well as each of improvement also, hence all r eligible for consideration of LTCG.
M. Hence LTCG = L - K = 70.03L Rs. N. amount invested in LTCG Tax Saving bonds = 50L O. amount invested in Res. property = 32L Rs. P. Total invested amount = N + O = 82L Rs.
As the amount in P above is more than M above, so no LTCG Tax liability is there.
Yes u r right.
Thanks
Ashal
Dear Ashal!
Thanks for the prompt response and detailed calculations.
One more modification would be introduced to this calculation because I did not furnish you with that info.
I had financed this purchase in 1988 with the help of Loans from BHEL and Cement Corporation of India. I have not preserved the interest records. The amount was borrowed in 1984, 1985 and 1986 and repaid completely in 1991.
As I do not know the interest quantum, I do not know what to do with that.
Any suggestions would be welcome. Thanks once again.
Subasu
Dear subasu, as the records of loans are not with u, also the applicable FYs r also date very back.
Hence I'm sorry to say that u can't do anything now.
Q. - Is it better to go for an annuity like Jeevan Tarang of LIC or an MF with term insurance.Annuity offers returns for lifetime whereas MF does not.Also please tell me which is the best annuity available.My age is 39 and i am due to retire on age 58? - Vinod Pulari
ANS. - Dear Vinod Pulari, Plz. don't opt Jeevan Tarang, for ur age the return from this policy r very poor. Sample this - For a 5L cover, for ur age, the prem. for 20Y policy = 24610 Rs.
Hence total prem. paid over 20 years = 492200 Rs. For past 4 years the LIC have announced 48 Rs. bonus per annum per 000 sum assured, so we can take this as benchmark for our calculation. At the end of 20 year, u 'll get amount = 20*48*500 = 480000 Rs. or appx. ur prem. back. From 21st year u 'll get 25000 Rs. (5% of 5L Rs.) as survival benefit every year tax free till u r alive. After ur death, ur nominee 'll get the basic sum assured of 5L Rs. back as maturity benefit. Now compare this with the combo of PPF+Term Plan (Anmol Jeevan from LIC). Plz. note cheaper term insurance plans r available in market but i'm limiting it to LIC's Anmol Jeevan for comparing of product within same Ins. co. The annual prem. for 5L cover for 20 Year plan = 3193 Rs. difference in the prem. = 24610-3193 = 21417 Rs. Invest this amt. every year in PPF, at the end of 20 year, the amt. in PPF = 10.58L
Withdraw from PPF amt. equal to bonus declared by LIC = 10.58L - 4.8L = 5.78L Rs. This 5.78L Rs. 'll remain in PPF 'll earn interest for next year. After 1 year the interest on 5.78L Rs. = 46240 out of which u may withdraw 25K Rs. as tax free. Balance amt. 'll remain with PPF & like vise every year, u 'll withdraw only 25K & the PPF amt. 'll keep on increasing. Plz. note in this case even after 25 years or 30 years from now onwards or for ur age of 65-70, at ur death, ur nominee 'll receive more than what they 'll get in Jeevan Tarang (the basic sum assured of 5L Rs. only). Now do tell me, what r u going to opt?
Plz. note here i have not advised to invest in any Eq. MFs for betterment of return. U r already aware that PPF is one of the safest scheme.
Dear friends, a lot of u were demanding details on the NPS, so for benefit of all of you. Here i'm giving some details of this.
WHO CAN INVEST? Scheme is open to all Indian citizens aged between 18 years and 55 years.
WHERE TO INVEST?? You can invest from any of the 285 Point of Service across India, run by 22 Point of Presence Providers(POP) including SBI, its 7 Associate Banks, ICICI Bank, LIC, Reliance Capital, etc. Once registered, the Central Recordkeeping Agency (CRA) will give you a Permanent Retirement Account Number (PRAN) along with Telephone and Internet Passwords.
HOW DOES THE NPS WORK?? Just like a Depository maintains Demat Accounts, likewise your Records are maintained by the Depositories. Six Different Pension Fund Managers would invest the Amount Invested by the Commonn People into Different Asset Classes classifed as Equity (E) Government Securities (G) Debt Instruments (C)
The Six Fund Managers are ICICI Prudential pension Management\ IDFC Pension Fund Management Kotak MahindraPension Fund Reliance Capital Pension Fund, SBI Pension Fund UTI Retirement solutions
Depending on the efficiency of the Fund Manager, these Contributions would Grow and accumulate over the years. You do need to mention the Fund Manager of your Choice, without this, your Application is liable to be rejected. The Default Investment is called the Auto Choice Lifestyle Fund. For a investor below 35 years of age, 50% of investment amount will go into E(Equity), one-fifth into asset class G(Govt Securities), and the rest into asset class C(Debt Instruments). From the age of 36, the default proportion going to equities decrease annually and investment percentage in government securities will increase such that by the age of 60, these investments will gradually be adjusted so that only 10% remains in equities, another 10% in corporate bonds and 80% in government bonds.
MINIMUM CONTRIBUTION : Minimum Contribution per annum is 6000 and you can contribute even as low as 500, at least 4 times a year. You can invest through Cash, Cheque or DD at the POP. There is no upper ceiling for your annual contribution but Tax Benefits is capped at 1 lakh under Sec80C. The Investor HAS to invest at least once every quarter. In case of default, you will have to pay Rs.100per annum and also need to pay the required minimum amount to reactivate your Account. Also during this period of your non-payment, your Corpus will keep getting reduced because the NPS will keep charging its Expenses against your Units. The Account will be closed as and when the Value of your Account falls to Zero.
WHERE IS MY MONEY INVESTED??? You have got the Right to decide where your money is invested. Please note, that you cannot invest more than 50% in Equity and Fund Managers cannot in invidual stocks but only in Index Funds.
RETURNS : On Completion of 60 years, the investor`s accumulated amount gets transformed into a lumpsum towards buying Annuity for a steady stream of payments for the rest of the Investor`s life. The Insurance Companies, who come into the picture now, with their expertise will compute as to how long the investor could survive and offer flexible investment and payment options on annuities. If the subscriber exits the scheme before the age of 60, s/he may keep one fifth of the accumulated saving and invest the rest in annuities offered by insurance companies. A person who exits NPS when his age is between 60 and 70 has to use 40% of the corpus to buy an annuity and can take the rest of the money out in one go or in instalments. If a subscriber dies, the nominee has the option to receive the entire pension wealth as a lump sum.
LAST YEAR THE NPS GAVE A RETURN OF 14.82% WHILE HANDLING THE CORPUS OF CIVIL SERVICE PENSIONS.
TAX ANGLE : At present, the NPS is to be Taxed at the time of Withdrawal. The Pension Fund Regulator has taken up the issue with the Finance Ministry to address the anamoly and the decision is expected within next year or so.
NEGATIVES : 1) Though the Fund Management is ridiculously low at a miniscule 0.0009% per annum, the Cost of Opening an Account(Rs.50), Annual Maintenance Charge(Rs.350) and a Per Transaction Charge of Rs.10 actually makes the NPS COSTLIER than a Regular Mutual Fund with a 500 monthly sip. The cost works out to around Rs.350 as fixed cost on every Rs.2000 he contributes. Unless the Govt steps in to correct this, NPS would be a failure with the small savers. 2) No Tax Concession on Withdrawals. 3) No premature Withdrawals allowed expect for Critical Illness, building/buying a house; Even at sixty, you can only withdraw as cash 60 per cent of the corpus, the rest must be used to buy an annuity. 4) You need to compulsorily buy Immediate Annuity with 80% of the Money accumulated, if you want to Withdraw before you are 60.
POSITIVES : 1) The Investor has the option of shifting from One fund Manager to another by instructing his POP to do so. This facility is available between May 1 and May 15 every year.
2) Even relocating to another city will not affect your investment as the PRAN remains the same. 3) The Monthly/Quarterly Contribution towards the NPS will be partly routed towards Equity which will automatically ensure Rupee cost Averaging and ensure High Returns and thus ensure 'higher than inflation' returns. 4) Investment upto Rs.1 lakh is Tax Deductible under Sec80c. 5) For Investors with slightly larger amounts and investing 4 times a year, the charges are attractively low. The NPS wins hands down on this matter.
CONCLUSION : This is the Best thing to have happened to the Indian Investors who have not had much of a choice regarding Pension earlier. The benefits of Compounded Returns that the NPS offers will be immense. If the NPS is promoted in the right way, it will be no less than a Revolution. The Tax on Withdrawal, for me, is a blunder and will be rectified by the Govt sooner rather than later. The Interim Withdrawal too may be allowed in future, which will make this product that much more attractive. The best option as of now i think is to remain invested in max. Eq. for person below age 50 & above that should go for the LifeCycle Fund. The Low Charges and Automatic Rupee Cost Averaging makes NPS a Better Option than the Pension Plans offered by Insurance Companies.
But still some loose ends are there so as of now enter in NPS with minimum annual commitement of 6K Rs. & wait for the dust to settle & the clarity on taxation matters & then bump up ur investment in NPS.